Michael Vick’s Redemptive Story

This week Forbes released another top 10 list based on surveys by E-Poll Market Research—this one touting (of all things) the NFL’s Most-Disliked Players and crowning Eagles’ starting quarterback, Michael Vick, as number one.

To be sure, Michael Vick has made some mistakes—some serious mistakes. Being promoted as the “next big thing” can go to the head of any young athlete. That seems to have been the case with Mr. Vick. However, I am flummoxed that after four years on the straight and narrow he would top the list of the NFL’s most disliked players.

I happen to love stories of redemption. One of the hallmarks of Christianity is the message of redemption. In the broad sense, the Bible is largely a collection of one redemptive story after another. If one gets nothing else from reading the Bible they cannot miss the overarching theme that there is always hope no matter how far a person has fallen.

Consider Judah, for example, son number four of the patriarch Jacob. According to patriarchal practices a man’s firstborn son is privileged with a double inheritance and priority in rank over younger siblings. Judah is outraged when his father Jacob flagrantly violates ancient patriarchal protocol and bypasses ten older sons in favor of Joseph, son of his second wife Rachel. Judah comes unhinged and actually sells his younger half-brother to slave traders. We call that human trafficking today.

Then there is the Apostle Paul who in his pre-apostolic days was a religious terrorist—tracking down, terrorizing, and persecuting Christians, then agreeing to their murders.

Compose a list of the “Most Disliked Men in the Bible” and Judah and Paul are both in the running—significantly outdistancing any NFL player considered by Forbes.

But God’s redemptive powers are at work in both stories, and both men make dramatic U-turns. Judah later puts his own life on the line to rescue the youngest of Jacob’s sons. Paul becomes the great apostle of the Christian gospel and will eventually suffer martyrdom in the movement he once fought to crush. The reversals are staggering, but much needed reminders that no one is beyond hope.

Redemptive powers are at work in the Michael Vick story too. Animal lovers (who presumably are well-represented among the 1,100 fans polled) may have a long memory, but the lovers of redemptive stories will find much to celebrate here.

I don’t think its overstating things to say Michael Vick’s story is possibly the most significant story playing out in the NFL today.

Naming Vick as the most disliked NFL player of 2013 serves no useful purpose and cheats us all of the kind of hope his story offers—the kind of hope we need to hear when there is so much in the news to dishearten.

Vick’s U-turn sends a message of hope to countless young men who have gotten off-track and need a story like this to remind them there is hope for them too. The beautiful father-son relationship between Vick and the highly esteemed Super Bowl winning coach, Tony Dungy, is a welcome breath of fresh air in our father-hungry culture. The Philadelphia Eagles’ offer of a second chance to a gifted athlete underscores the possibility that there can be new beginnings. With God’s help, Vick is turning his life around. Four years and counting, he is moving steadily forward.

Rather than pointing to the past, wouldn’t we all be better served to be cheering him on? For that matter, maybe Forbes could use a little redemption too—a polling U-turn by throwing out the “Most Disliked NFL Players” poll to consider polling the “Most Redemptive Stories of 2013.”


Published on the Huffington Post:  http://huff.to/18QJNSW

About carolyncustisjames

This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Michael Vick’s Redemptive Story

  1. Caryn R. says:

    Thanks for the good reminder, Carolyn. I confess to having a hard time forgiving dog-fighters (and animal abusers), but the redemption stories of so many pit bulls (including my own) remind me every day that God is doing amazing, redemptive work throughout ALL creation.

    For some great redemption stories surrounding this, check out: “The Lost Dogs: Michael Vick's Dogs and Their Tale of Rescue and Redemption.” Amazing book!


  2. Jonathan says:

    Thank you for this, Carolyn. One thing is certain: If people judged me for mistakes I made in my past the way they judge Michael Vick, I'd have no friends today.


  3. Agreed! Thank you for reminding all of us that we are never beyond redemption…and hope. Self-righteousness (aka self-rightness) breeds an impatience for others and a disdain for authentic grace.



  4. sandy says:

    Living in the Philadelphia and being an Eagles fan since birth, I have seen a HUGE about face in the fans. You all know about the famous Philadelphia fans. They may have thought Andy Reid was crazy to sign a contract with Michael but I haven't heard them complaining since. (except for his proclivity to injury).


  5. Carolyn says:

    We live the Jonah story too–where we would refuse grace, redemption, and hope to someone else whose story is displayed in public and fail to realize our own repeated and desperate need for the same.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s